Review by Michele Bolay
In honor of the holiday season, I went back and looked at my list of favorite children’s holiday books, and this was right at the top: The House Without a Christmas Tree by Gail Rock, one in a short series of novels about the incomparable 10-year-old Addie Mills. Unfortunately, the series is out of print, but several libraries in the system still have copies, and this particular title was filmed as a must-see made-for-TV movie in the 1970s that is still available on DVD.
I was curious as to what other people thought about the book, which is truly a hidden classic that not many have read. I found this delightful review on Goodreads from a friend of a friend named Tatiana, and it says it all:
“I was looking for a Christmas novel that 1) had heart, 2) wasn’t sappy, and 3) didn’t make me cry. I found it in The House Without a Christmas Tree: sweet, concise (I read it today), and old-fashioned in the best way. It’s the story of Addie Mills, a fiesty 10-year-old in 1946, who can’t understand why her father won’t allow them to have a Christmas tree. Father and daughter both have trouble communicating with those they care about, and so it’s good they have Grandma to bridge the gap. Grandma tries to make Addie see the situation from her father’s point of view, that of a man who’s still grieving the loss of his wife, while simultaneously explaining to her son the importance of loving the ones still with us. But it takes a series of miscues, including Addie dragging a tree through town (twice!) before all can be resolved. A lovely story that leaves you hoping there really are girls like Addie Mills in the world and wishing you could know one.”
The only thing I’d change about this review is that it does, in fact, make me cry. But not because it’s deliberately “tear-jerking” or emotionally manipulative in any way. Rather, because it’s a lovely story told simply and honestly, and out of that simplicity and honesty comes the true emotion of the piece. Not to be missed.
There is also a very nice, but brief, fan site for Addie. Check it out!
And there is a lovely Time article praising the adaptation: “The Little Christmas Classic That Could.”
Check availability on The House Without a Christmas Tree!
About the reviewer: Michele Bolay loves Christmas movies, but then again, who doesn’t?